As the Internet of Things (IoT) and cloud services become more common, inventions involving multiple connected devices are becoming increasingly important. In this article, we call these “system inventions.”
Because the Internet works across national borders, these systems may also operate across different countries.
However, patent rights are granted by each individual country. There is no single patent that is valid worldwide.
This difference creates special challenges when seeking patent protection for cloud services and systems that use overseas servers.
What Is a System Patent?
As an example, imagine a system S1 with the following three functions:
・Input function (F1): receives data D1 from a user.
・Processing function (F2): performs special processing on D1 and creates D2.
・Output function (F3): outputs D2.

These three functions may all be provided by a single standalone device. They may also be divided among several devices.
For example, a client device (such as a PC or smartphone) may provide the input function F1 and the output function F3, while a server performs the processing function F2.
In this case, the invention may be claimed as:
・A system including F1, F2, and F3.
・A system including a client with F1 and F3, and a server with F2.
In this article, a patent that covers multiple functions performed by multiple devices (such as a server and a client) will be called a system patent.
The following examples show possible ways to define the invention in patent claims.
Whether each claim can be granted depends on whether it meets the requirements for patent protection.
Server Patents
Suppose another company places a server with F2 in Japan, but places the client with F1 and F3 in the United States.
If you only own the Japanese system patent, it may be difficult to claim direct patent infringement.
The server in Japan performs only F2.
The client performs F1 and F3 in the United States.
Therefore, the devices located in Japan alone do not meet all the requirements of the system claim.
(Indirect infringement may sometimes be possible, but this article focuses only on direct infringement.)
If this arrangement is likely, it can be useful to seek a patent covering the server itself, in addition to the system patent:
・A server including F2.
Since the server with F2 is located in Japan, a Japanese server patent may provide a direct basis for alleging infringement, provided that the server meets all the claim requirements.
In many systems, the server performs the core processing.
Therefore, a server patent can be an effective way to protect the most important part of the invention.
Client Patents
Another option is to seek a patent covering the client itself:
・A client including F1 and F3.
Now suppose another company installs its server with F2 in Singapore, while the client with F1 and F3 is located in Japan.
A Japanese server patent would not provide a straightforward basis for targeting the server located in Singapore.
However, since the client is located in Japan, infringement of the client patent can still be established.
In practice, client patents often have an important advantage over server patents.
It is usually much easier to verify how a client device operates than to inspect another company's server.
As a result, detecting infringement is often easier with a client patent.
Many Possible System Configurations
Let's look at a more complex example.
Assume a system S2 includes four functions:
・Input function (F1)
・Processing function (F2A)
・Processing function (F2B)
・Output function (F3)
The inventor may originally imagine the following configuration:
・The client performs F1 and F3.
・The server performs F2A and F2B.
However, the client might also perform F2A, in addition to F1 and F3.
Modern smartphones can handle complex processing. Some functions that require substantial computing power may therefore run on the client instead of the server.
For this reason, several different patent claims may be appropriate.
Possible System Patents
・A system including F1, F2A, F2B, and F3.
・A system including a client with F1 and F3, and a server with F2A and F2B.
・A system including a client with F1, F2A, and F3, and a server with F2B.
Possible Server Patents
・A server including F2A and F2B.
・A server including F2B.
Possible Client Patents
・A client including F1 and F3.
・A client including F1, F2A, and F3.
There may be even more variations.
For example, F2A and F2B may be performed by two different servers instead of one.
In that case, additional claims may include:
・A system including a client with F1 and F3, a first server with F2A, and a second server with F2B.
・A server including F2A.
How to Draft Useful Patent Claims for System Inventions
System inventions may operate across national borders, while patent rights are territorial. This makes claim drafting especially important.
When preparing patent applications for system inventions, patent attorneys first identify the minimum set of functions needed to provide the service.
Next, they decide which functions:
・should be performed by the server,
・should be performed by the client,
・could be performed by either the server or the client, and
・could even be performed by a third type of device.
After that, they consider every device that might perform all or part of those functions, including servers, clients, and other devices.
By comparing these arrangements, they can choose claim language that may qualify for a patent and provide useful, enforceable protection.
They also consider different ways to divide the functions and different ways to describe them, from specific technical details to more general functions. The same invention may be expressed in several ways. With careful drafting, one patent can sometimes offer the practical value of several—or even many—patents.
If the claims cover only the entire system, a competitor may find a way around them by moving functions to another device or an overseas server.
Whether such a change actually avoids infringement depends on the claims and the circumstances.
The aim is to obtain patent rights that are practical to use and enforce, as well as to secure a patent grant.
Consider the System, Its Components, and Where It Operates
For systems involving overseas servers or multiple service providers, consider several forms of protection.
These may include claims covering the whole system, the server, the client, a computer program, or an information-processing method.
The claim design should reflect how functions can be divided among devices and where the service will be provided.
It should also consider which parts of the system can realistically be checked for infringement.
Carefully drafted server and client claims can strengthen protection and make enforcement more practical.