Page top

Language: JA | EN

Why Include Dependent Claims in a Patent Application?

Takuya Mitani | 2018/11/04

Independent and Dependent Claims


A patent’s scope of protection is defined by its claims.
Suppose Patent P1 contains the following two claims:

Claim 1
A device that dispenses an appropriate amount of a drink when Button 1 is pressed.
Claim 2
The device of Claim 1, which also dispenses ice when Button 2 is pressed.


Claim 1 means that others may not make or sell, without permission, a device that dispenses an appropriate amount of a drink when a button is pressed. This is Feature A.
Claim 2 means that others may not make or sell, without permission, a device that dispenses an appropriate amount of a drink when one button is pressed and also dispenses ice when another button is pressed. This is Feature A plus Feature B.

Claim 1 is an independent claim. Claim 2 depends on another claim—in this case, Claim 1—and is therefore called a dependent claim.

A product that falls within Claim 1 does not always fall within Claim 2. For example, a cup-style vending machine may dispense a drink but not ice. It has Feature A, but not Feature B. However, a product that falls within Claim 2 also falls within Claim 1.

An independent claim is usually broader than a dependent claim. There are rare exceptions, but this article does not discuss them.

This raises a question: if a dependent claim provides narrower protection than an independent claim, why include it?

Why Include Dependent Claims?


To find a path to a patent

An applicant may believe Feature A is patentable, but Feature A alone may not be enough to obtain a patent. Adding Feature B may improve the chance of getting a patent. A device that dispenses ice as well as a drink may be more useful and may involve more of an improvement than a device that only dispenses a drink.

If an application includes only Claim 1, which covers Feature A, and the examiner finds it unpatentable, it may be difficult to know how much more must be added to obtain a patent.

If the application also includes Claim 2, which covers Features A and B, and the examiner finds Claim 2 patentable, the applicant has a clearer fallback position: give up the broader Claim 1 and pursue protection for Claim 2.

The applicant may also be able to pursue a claim that is narrower than Claim 1 but broader than Claim 2. For example, instead of limiting the claim to ice, it might cover a device that dispenses an ingredient—such as ice or hot water—to adjust the drink’s temperature or concentration.

To preserve ideas that may be worth claiming

If an idea is described in the patent specification, it may be possible to make it the subject of a claim later or to use it to amend an existing claim, subject to applicable rules.

However, searching the specification later for ideas that could become claims can take time, and an idea may be overlooked. It can be more efficient to include, as dependent claims when filing, all the improvements that are already known and considered important.

Also, an idea described in the specification is not always explained in enough detail to support a claim later. Writing it as a dependent claim at the time of filing encourages the applicant to describe it in a way that takes examination into account and may make it easier to obtain protection.


Why Keep Dependent Claims?


A patent may later be challenged and invalidated.
Suppose Patent P1 has only Claim 1, which covers Feature A. If someone later finds a document, D1, that describes Feature A, Patent P1 may be invalidated.

But if Patent P1 also includes Claim 2, which covers Features A and B, Claim 2 may survive even if Claim 1 is invalidated. Dependent claims can reduce the risk that the entire patent will be lost.

Consider a company that sells Product Y, which has Features A and B.

Case 1: The patent has only Claim 1
Suppose Patent P1 includes only Claim 1, which covers Feature A. Because Product Y has Feature A, it falls within the scope of the claim.
Now suppose Company X finds prior-art document D1, which describes Feature A. The patent’s only claim, Claim 1, may be invalidated. If Patent P1 is invalidated, Product Y no longer falls within its protection.

Case 2: The patent has Claims 1 and 2
Now suppose Patent P1 includes Claim 1, covering Feature A, and Claim 2, covering Features A and B.
If Company X finds D1, Claim 1 may be invalidated. But Claim 2 may survive because it also requires Feature B. Since Product Y has both Features A and B, it may still fall within the scope of the surviving Claim 2.

It is usually harder to find a document that describes both Features A and B than one that describes only Feature A. This can make it more likely that some protection will survive.

If Claim 1 may be invalidated but Claim 2 appears harder to invalidate, Company X may be less willing to challenge the patent.

Case 3: The dependent claim adds a feature the product does not have
Suppose Patent P1 includes Claim 1, covering Feature A, and Claim 2, covering Features A and C.
If D1 invalidates Claim 1 but Claim 2 survives, Product Y will not fall within Claim 2 if it does not have Feature C. In that situation, the patent may survive, but the surviving dependent claim does not protect Product Y.

When drafting dependent claims, it is important to anticipate features that a product with Feature A is likely to include in the future. In the examples above, Feature B is useful for protecting Product Y, while Feature C is not.

The value of a dependent claim depends on its likely usefulness. A dependent claim should have a clear reason for being included.

Dependent Claims and Divisional Applications


Dependent claims can also help identify opportunities for divisional applications.
For example, suppose the claims are structured as follows:
Claim 1 (independent claim) = A
Claim 2 (dependent claim) = A + B (= claim 1 + B)
Claim 3 (dependent claim) = A + B + C (= claim 2 + C)
Claim 4 (dependent claim) = A + B + D (= claim 2 + D)

Suppose the examiner finds Claims 1 and 2 unpatentable but finds Claims 3 and 4 patentable. The applicant may give up Claims 1 and 2 and amend the claims as follows:
Claim 1 (independent term) = A + B + C
Claim 2 (independent clause) = A + B + D

If the examiner finds Claims 3 and 4 patentable, that may suggest that Features C and D contribute to patentability. Depending on what the specification supports and how the application is examined, the applicant may also be able to explore other combinations, such as A + C, A + D, B + C, B + D, C + D, C alone, or D alone, through divisional applications.

Including dependent claims can make it easier to consider whether additional patent protection is available after the first patent is granted.

This can be especially useful for software inventions. They often contain several small ideas, and a point other than the main idea originally targeted may turn out to be more valuable.

It is also common to find useful ideas in another company’s patent specification that were not included in its claims. If those ideas had been claimed, they might have created a serious problem. That is one reason to review whether additional protection can be pursued, even after a patent has been granted.