Page top

Language: JA | EN

How Patents Shape Business Rules

Takuya Mitani | 2018/12/08
A patent does more than protect an invention.
Within the scope of its claims, it can restrict what competitors may make or sell.
In this sense, a patent can be seen as a tool for shaping the rules of business.

Making Your Own Rules


When I started working as a patent attorney, I began to feel that patent law is essentially a tool for creating laws.
The claims of a patent work very much like legal rules.

For example, imagine a patent P with the following claim:

[Claim 1] A tea dispenser that automatically serves the right amount of tea when a button is pressed.

If patent P is granted, no one other than the patent owner may make or sell, without permission, a device that falls within this claim.
A company that happened to be planning such a tea dispenser would have its business plan destroyed once the patent is granted.


When patent P is granted, it is almost like a new law saying:
“No one except the patent owner may make or sell a device that automatically serves the right amount of tea when a button is pressed.”

Contracts only bind the parties who signed them.
A Japanese patent, by contrast, can affect anyone conducting business in Japan if their product or activity falls within the patent’s scope.
Most people are not planning to make such a tea dispenser, so it may look as though the patent has no effect. But for some businesses, the effect can be extremely serious.

Filing a patent application is, in a sense, an attempt to use patent law as a legislative tool to create “your own rules” that work in your favor.

A patent also has legal force, just like normal laws.
The patent owner may seek an order to stop infringement and claim damages.
Criminal penalties may also apply in certain cases. However, what the patent owner can stop depends on the scope of the claims.

Companies conduct business in areas where they can apply their own rules—their “territory”—or where no one’s rules apply yet—a “free zone.”
If a company can keep many customers within its own rules, it can profit greatly.

Your Rules in Other Countries


Even if you are Japanese, if you obtain a U.S. patent, you can enforce your own rules in the United States.
Likewise, if an American company obtains a Japanese patent, businesses in Japan may have to follow that company’s rules when their activities fall within the patent’s scope.

This is why countries with weaker technological power often fear that foreign companies—especially from advanced countries—will obtain many patents in their country.
They worry that their business environment will gradually be occupied by foreign companies’ rules.
Therefore, such countries may want to limit the power of patents.

In many international disputes about intellectual property, advanced countries take the lead.
They naturally want their rules to be respected in other countries.

In Japan, ordinary laws are carefully reviewed by the Cabinet Legislation Bureau and various committees before they are enacted.
But a patent is created mainly through discussions between the patent examiner and the applicant’s representative, the patent attorney.

Examiners try to keep patents narrow so they do not affect others too much, or they may decide not to grant a patent.
Patent attorneys try to obtain the broadest possible rights for their clients.

Changing the Rules of the Game


In 1996, a curious patent application (JP H8-251999) was filed in Japan.
It contains claims like the following (with some errors corrected):

[Claim 1] Everything: all matter, all space, and all time.
[Claim 2] Everything written here. Reading by every possible means. Reading with all eyes. Reading using every eye learned here.
[Claim 3] All laws and rules involved here.
...
[Claim 30] All things in the world and in the universe.

It sounds like an attempt to take control of everything in Japan.
If such a patent were granted—which it was not—no one could use or make “anything.”
People would not even be able to sell objects or time, so all business activity in Japan would stop.

This strange application, however, makes us think about the true nature of patent law.

When A transfers a patent to B, A is essentially changing “my rules” into “your rules.”
Obtaining, licensing, and transferring patents can be seen as changing the rules of the business game among its players.


Business can be viewed as a game whose conditions change according to the market and the law.
Patent law is a legitimate tool for influencing and shaping the rules of that game.
In extreme terms, it can be used as a tool to shape the business environment to your advantage.

This means that the true mission of an intellectual property (IP) department is to create rules, enforce rules, and detect changes in the rules.
A group of patents used to protect a company’s business area is called a patent portfolio. Patents may also protect some business models.