Page top

Language: JA | EN

Why Do Companies Get Patents? 7 Benefits of a Patent Strategy

Takuya Mitani | 2019/03/01
Some business owners may wonder, “We rarely use our patents, so why should we get them?”
A patent is more than a right to sue another company. Patents can protect products, create income, improve a company’s position in negotiations, build trust, and encourage employees to develop new ideas.

Getting a patent can also be a meaningful achievement for both the company and the inventor. Patents can serve many purposes, including protection, reputation, marketing, licensing, and business assets. Understanding these purposes is a good starting point for deciding what patents your company needs and how to use them.

(1) Protect Your Products and Services with Patents


This is the most basic and traditional use of a patent.
A company develops a product and protects its key features with a patent. Within the scope of the patent, the company can prevent competitors from making or selling similar products without permission. If the patent is strong and the product is attractive, the company may be able to sell it without direct competition and earn significant profits.

For example, imagine that Company X analyzes a large amount of stock price data and discovers this pattern:
“When a stock price reaches condition S, it is likely to rise sharply within a few days.”

Company X then develops trading system T, which gives a “buy” signal when a stock reaches condition S.
At the same time, Company X obtains Patent P1 for a system that notifies users when a stock reaches condition S.


Because of Patent P1, competitors may be prevented from making similar trading systems that fall within the patent’s scope. Company X may be able to sell trading system T with a high profit margin.

Without Patent P1, competitors could make similar systems. The original product might even lose its place in the market.

For companies with limited sales resources or capital, patents can sometimes be a lifeline when they start a new business.
A patent can do more than protect an invention: it can also limit competitors’ options and help create a business environment that favors the patent owner.

(2) Earn Income Through Patent Licensing


A patent owner can allow another company to use the patent in exchange for royalty payments. This is called patent licensing.

There are different ways to pay royalties:
An initial royalty is a lump-sum payment made when the agreement is signed.
A running royalty is paid for each product made or sold.
The two payment methods can also be combined.
 
A patent owner is like a landowner.
Just as a landowner receives rent for allowing others to use land, a patent owner receives royalties for allowing others to use patented technology.

The patent owner must decide whether to earn money by selling its own products or by allowing another company to make products and paying royalties.
This choice is part of business strategy as well as patent strategy. The best option depends on which approach is likely to create more value for the company.
 

(3) Sell a Patent as a Business Asset


A patent can also be sold.
Some businesses, called patent aggregators, buy patents that may be useful to other companies.

I once spoke with a company from another country that had bought many patents from a Japanese company. The company did not tell me the details, but I think some of the hundreds of patents it bought were patents it wanted to obtain—and some may have been patents it wanted to keep out of circulation.

A patent can therefore be both a way to protect a product and a business asset that can be sold or transferred as part of a business deal.

(4) Use Patents in Cross-Licensing and Negotiations


A company may allow another company to use its patent in exchange for permission to use the other company’s patent. This is called a cross-license agreement.

A cross-license can be seen as a non-aggression pact that helps maintain “patent peace.”
It can also let companies combine their technologies to make more attractive products.
A patent pool, in which member companies contribute patents and allow one another to use them, is another way to share patent rights.

For example, imagine that Company Y develops a system that analyzes a user’s investment results and shows how the user compares with other investors. Company Y obtains Patent P2 for displaying a user’s investment ability as a score based on the user’s investment record.

Company X might want to add the feature covered by Patent P2 to its trading system T. Company Y might also want to make a trading system that uses the feature covered by Patent P1.

The two companies could enter into a cross-license agreement. If the agreement helps both companies make more attractive products, it may benefit the companies and their users. Users, for example, could use both functions in one system.

However, cross-licensing is not always the best choice. If a company agrees too easily, its product may lose its unique appeal and competitive advantage. In some cases, it may be better for each company to focus on its own technical area.

Patents can give a company more power in negotiations because patent rights can prevent others from using the patented invention without permission. But negotiation power does not depend only on the number of patents. It also depends on whether the company owns the right combination of patents covering the technologies its business needs. This group of patents is called a patent portfolio.


(5) Encourage Inventions and Build an Innovative Company Culture


Getting a patent can bring recognition to the inventor.
For example, engineers can list their patents on their resumes to show their experience and value when looking for a new job.

Encouraging employees to file patent applications can also help build a company culture that values new ideas. This benefit may seem small, but it can become very important over time.

When inventors prepare a patent application, they put their ideas into words and organize them logically. This makes their knowledge clearer and easier to share. Once knowledge is clearly organized, it may help the company develop new ideas.
When company leaders show interest in inventions and patents, they send employees a message: the company values new ideas.
Patent activity can therefore help create an organization where future inventions are more likely to emerge.

(6) Show Technical Strength and Build Trust


Patents can show a company’s technical strengths and help build its brand.

When a company seeks investment or a loan, its patents may be considered as part of the company’s evaluation.
Investors may look at what technology the company has and whether it has taken steps to protect that technology.

Patents can also support negotiations when a company receives investment from a potential competitor. For a startup or a new business that does not yet have many sales or a long track record, patents can help explain what makes its technology different and why it may have future value.

(7) Enforce Patent Rights Against Competitors


Patents can be used to stop competitors from copying an invention or entering a market with products that fall within the patent’s scope.
A patent owner may send a warning or seek a license, and the patent may help the owner negotiate from a stronger position.
The owner does not always need to file a lawsuit for the patent to have a deterrent effect.

Enforcing patent rights is not always the best or most productive choice. Still, patents can be legal tools for limiting a competitor’s business activities.

Use Patents as Part of Your Business Strategy


The uses of patents are not limited to the examples above.
Companies may find new ways to use patent rights as their businesses change.

The first question should not be “How many patents should we get?”
Instead, a company should ask what it wants to achieve in its business and how patents can help.

A company may want to protect a product, earn licensing income, improve its position in negotiations, or show its technical strengths to others.
The company’s goals affect what patents it should seek and when it should seek them.

A company can also consider patents while it is planning a new business or product, instead of waiting until development is complete.
It may be possible to protect the basic idea behind a business before development begins.

Patents are not only a concern for engineers or intellectual property staff.
Decisions about how to obtain and use patents are closely connected to management decisions about which markets a company will serve and how it will earn profits.