Page top

Language: JA | EN

Future-Focused Patent Strategy: How to Protect Tomorrows Markets

Takuya Mitani | 2019/04/01
A patent can protect more than a product or technology that a company is developing today.
A company can also think about how technology and society may change, what products and services people may need, and how to protect an opportunity in a future market.

If a company waits until the future market is clear, many competitors may already have entered it.
By then, it may be difficult to obtain a strong patent.
It is useful to think about future needs (NEED) and wants (WANT) while the market is still taking shape.

Monopoly Systems and the Patent System


The patent system is similar to a monopoly system.
Patents may once have been closely associated with the exclusive right to sell a product.

In ancient China, the Tang Dynasty controlled the right to sell salt and imposed high taxes on government-approved salt.
Since salt was essential for daily life, people had no choice but to buy it.

As a result, the Tang government earned enormous profits. Later dynasties continued using the same salt monopoly system.

A patent gives its owner an exclusive right to an invention for a limited time.
Within the scope of the patent, the owner may be able to prevent others from using the invention without permission.
If a company obtains a patent for a core technology that many people must use, it may be able to charge a high price for products using that technology.

This mechanism is similar to a monopoly system.
However, unlike a monopoly system, patents have a limited term.
A patent’s value can also change as technology develops during that term. It is not stable like the value of an essential product such as salt.


NEED and WANT in Future Markets


The patent system temporarily grants exclusive rights to people who open up a new market with new technology.
Creating a new market can mean creating something people need or want.

NEED and WANT are also used in marketing.
Here, they are useful ways to think about technologies that may lead to valuable patents.

NEED technologies are technologies people must use or would have difficulty doing without.
WANT technologies are technologies people want to use.

If a technology is as essential as salt, a patent covering it may become very valuable. Patents for technologies that nobody needs or wants are likely to have little value.

(1) NEED Technologies

Patents for technologies that people must use can become very strong.

For example, imagine that a company obtains a basic patent for automatic braking technology at an early stage.
Later, automatic braking becomes widely used and is eventually required by law.
At that point, the patent may cover technology that car manufacturers must use.

If a company invests early in patents for automatic braking because it expects the technology to become essential, it may receive a large return.
Car manufacturers that fall behind may have to accept market conditions shaped by companies that moved earlier.

Technologies related to communication, safety, and measurement standards may become NEED technologies.
A technology that is optional today may become essential in the future because of new laws, standards, or changes in social infrastructure.
Looking beyond current needs can help a company identify technologies that may become necessary later.

(2) WANT Technologies

Technologies that many people want to use can also support valuable patents.

As technologies such as IoT, AI, and communication infrastructure become more common, new products and services may become possible.
For example, imagine a home refrigerator that automatically orders more beer when the supply is running low.
Such a product may be technically possible, but there may be practical challenges beyond the technology itself.
For example, communication networks, payment services, and delivery systems may need to be in place.

If a company expects people to want such a refrigerator in the future, it may consider obtaining patents before the product becomes common.
If the market develops and many people want the product, the value of the patent may rise.

It can be useful to consider technologies that cannot be fully developed today but seem technically possible in the near future.
Instead of only following trends such as AI, smart grids, eSports, and robotics, a company can ask how these technologies might change people’s lives and work. This may help the company imagine future products and services.

A patent that secures a position in a future market before competition becomes intense can be seen as a “blue-ocean patent.”


Patents for Current Markets and Future Markets


Patents for technologies that people clearly need today can have value from the time of filing.
However, competition in these fields is often intense, so it may be difficult to obtain broad and strong patent rights.
The market may also decline before a patent is granted.

For example, a company may obtain a patent for memory-saving technology.
But if memory becomes cheaper and more advanced, the need for that technology may fall, and the patent may quickly lose value.

Patents for technologies that people may need in the future can sometimes be broad and strong because the market is still developing.
But there is also a risk that the prediction will be wrong.

In the refrigerator example, society may never demand refrigerators that automatically order more beer. Or the market may appear only after the patent expires.
Sometimes a technology is too early for its time, and the patent expires before the market develops.

For this reason, filing a patent application as early as possible is not always the best strategy.
Filing early and filing at the right time are not always the same.
For inventions aimed at future markets, a company should consider both the risk that a competitor will file first and the risk that the patent term will run out before the business is ready.

Imagine the Near Future


One basic patent strategy is to predict where technology may lead, then seek protection for that future market at the right time.
Another strategy is to guide the market toward a field where the company already has patents, for example by licensing its patents or supporting standardization.

Paying attention to emerging technologies and thinking about the NEEDs and WANTs they may create can improve the quality of a company’s patents.

A company does not need to predict the future exactly.
It can start with technologies that are beginning to emerge and ask: “What will people need if this technology becomes common?” and “What would make people want to use it?”

A company can also imagine several possible futures and choose which technologies or services it should protect in each case.
A patent application can be a way to secure a place in a market before that market is fully visible.