Page top

Language: JA | EN

Patent Infringement Opinions: Assessing Their Economic Value

Takuya Mitani | 2018/12/26
When a company may be infringing another company’s patent, it must decide what to do.
Should it continue selling the product, change the design, or negotiate a license?
A patent infringement opinion can help the company make that decision.
This article compares the expected loss from patent infringement with the risk reduction that may result from a design change.

Estimating the Risk of Patent Infringement


Assume that your company’s product may infringe a third party’s patent, Patent P.
Let us suppose that the potential loss, if the risk materializes, is USD 10 million.

This loss amount (d) includes not only direct compensation but also:
・the risk of an order to stop product shipments;
・damage to the company’s reputation; and
・business delays caused by litigation or
negotiations.

Next, assume that the probability of this risk materializing (p1) is 10%.

This probability (p1) depends on two factors:
・pA: the probability that the patent owner will enforce the patent; and
・pB: the probability that a court will find infringement.
Generally, the patent owner is more likely to enforce the patent when the chance of a court finding infringement is high.
The patent may also be invalidated.


Based on these assumptions, the expected loss (y1) is:
y1 = d × p1 + 0 × (1 − p1)
= 10,000,000 × 10% + 0 × 90%
= USD 1,000,000

In practice, the risk cannot be calculated this simply.
The probability is not an objective number with one correct answer.
However, breaking the risk down—for example, into the chance of infringement and the chance that the patent may be invalidated—can turn a general concern into information that is useful for management decisions.

Estimating Risk Reduction Through a Design Change


Now assume that the company obtains a freedom-to-operate (FTO) analysis or patent infringement opinion. Based on the results, the company changes part of its product’s design.
After the design change, assume the probability of the risk materializing (p2) decreases to 1%.

Let the cost of the design change (c) be USD 500,000.

This cost includes:
・additional development costs;
・the risk of delaying the product launch; and
・the risk that the product may become less attractive and sell less well.

Of course, a design change may also improve the product and increase sales.

Assuming that the potential loss (d) remains unchanged, the new expected loss (y2) is:
y2 = d × p2 + 0 × (1 − p2) + c
= 10,000,000 × 1% + 0 × 99% + 500,000
= USD 600,000

In this example, the expected loss decreases by USD 400,000.
The design change reduced the expected loss by USD 400,000.
In that sense, the infringement opinion may be considered to have had an economic value of USD 400,000.
The value lies not in the opinion document itself, but in using the opinion to avoid or reduce the risk of infringement.

When Not Changing the Design Is Rational


Consider another scenario:
・Initial probability p1 = 3%
・Post-design probability p2 = 1%

Under the same conditions:
・y1 = USD 300,000
・y2 = USD 600,000

In this case, the calculation suggests that making the design change would increase the total expected cost.
Therefore, a company may rationally choose not to redesign and instead accept a certain level of risk.

However, this is based only on expected value.
Some decision-makers may still prefer a redesign because even a 3% chance of a USD 10 million loss is too significant to ignore.


A patent opinion provides information for management decisions. The company—the client—makes the final decision.

Quantifying Patent Infringement Risk


Even after a patent analysis or a design change, the risk may not fall to zero.
The future is uncertain, so it is easy to say, “There is some risk, so you should avoid it.”

However, business often requires taking some risks to achieve good results.

A patent infringement analysis should not simply give a yes-or-no answer: “infringement” or “no infringement.”
It should also try to show how large the risk is, so the company can manage it.

・Being too sensitive to risk may prevent a company from creating attractive products.
・Being too insensitive to risk may lead to serious losses.
A balanced approach is essential.

In practice, this requires:
・collecting as much relevant information as possible;
・developing arguments for both infringement and non-infringement;
・comparing both sides fairly; and
・presenting a professional opinion with confidence.

Preventive and Reactive Patent Opinions


Patent infringement opinions may be requested at different stages.
A company may request one during product planning, before the patent owner takes action.
It may also request one after receiving a warning that its product infringes a patent.

A patent opinion requested before a warning is a preventive opinion.
One requested after a warning is a reactive opinion.

A preventive opinion leaves room to consider flexible options, including a design change.
A reactive opinion is often requested when the patent owner is confident that infringement has occurred.
In that situation, the company may need arguments to show that its product does not infringe.

After receiving a warning, the company may also need to consider whether the patent can be invalidated, whether a design change is possible, and whether to negotiate a license.

An early infringement opinion can preserve several options, including redesigning the product.
Its economic value comes not only from assessing infringement, but also from helping the company compare business opportunities with the risks and make a reasonable decision.

Conclusion


The economic value of a patent infringement opinion lies in helping a company understand and reduce uncertainty so it can make a sound business decision.
A useful opinion does not promise to eliminate all risk.
It helps the company assess the risk, consider possible responses, and decide how to proceed.